Skip to content
LongIsland.io

Best Bagels on Long Island

Boiled, hand-rolled and gone by ten on a Sunday.

Popular Bagels Spots

Hilltop Bagel Cafe

Farmingville, Suffolk County

Olmo

New Haven

Wally's Bagels

North Babylon, Suffolk County

Bagels by Area

Narrow it down to the part of the island you are actually in.

Best Bagels in Nassau CountyBest Bagels in Suffolk CountyBest Bagels in North ShoreBest Bagels in South ShoreBest Bagels in North ForkBest Bagels in The HamptonsBest Bagels in HuntingtonBest Bagels in PatchogueBest Bagels in Garden CityBest Bagels in Port Jefferson

Related Categories

BakeriesBarsBreakfastBreweriesBrunchBurgersChineseCocktails

Long Islanders know Long Island best.

Think we missed one? Nominate your favorite restaurant, business, attraction or hidden gem.

Nominate a Business

Reach Long Island.

Partner with LongIsland.io through featured content, local guides, sponsorships and social video — and reach readers at the moment they are choosing where to eat, shop and hire.

Advertise With Us